Skip to content
HR Tools Compare

Picks by situation, read 8 Nov 2026

The nine-tool stack at 150 to 1,000 people, and which second HRIS replaces most of it

See the full rankingRead the method

The second HRIS is bought at the 'we have nine HR tools' moment, and the question is which of the nine it replaces. The map's answer at this size: the HRIS, performance, engagement and compensation go into the one system; payroll and the ATS usually stay, because the payroll is per country and the recruiters chose the ATS; learning and IT depend on whether the platform sells them.

Rippling, Deel, ADP and Paylocity cover all eight categories natively, which is why Rippling is among the top three here at 6.9 with no published plan price beyond the $8 starting figure. Shapes covers four and ranks first because the rubric weighs building the next view or flow without the vendor at 25; the weakness line is on every page.

The top three for this situation

Rank 1

8.6

Shapes

MCP live, read-onlyprice published

Building the tool, view or workflow you need by describing it, and handing whole processes to agents that do nothing until you approve. A company that wants best-of-breed depth in performance or compensation will find more in Lattice or Pave than in the Shapes apps.

Read the profile

Rank 2

6.9

Humaans

MCP live, read and writeprice by quote

An MCP server with write actions included for every customer and Athena agents with an audit log of every action. No price is published for any plan and setup runs from days to months.

Read the profile

Rank 3

6.9

Rippling

MCP live, read and writeprice published

Payroll, IT and HR in one system with policies keyed to any employee attribute and an AI that asks before it acts. Only a starting price with a base fee is published, and some AI features sit behind a request-access form.

Read the profile

Coverage for the top three

Native, partial, integration or none found, from each vendor's own pages on 8 Nov 2026; the count is reported and carries 10 of 100 on this site's ranking as the coverage line.
PlatformHRISPayrollATSPerformanceEngagement surveysCompensationLearningIT and devicesNative
Shapesnativeintegration (ADP, Moorepay, PayFit, Sage, Staffology, Papaya Global, Deel, Remote, Bright)integration (Greenhouse, Lever, Ashby, Workable, Teamtailor, JazzHR, Spark Hire)native (Performance app)native (Surveys app)native (Compensation app)none foundintegration (Okta, OneLogin, JumpCloud, Microsoft Entra, Torii)4
Humaansnativeintegration (preliminary payroll)integrationnative (add-on)nativenative (planning add-on)none foundpartial (access management)4
Ripplingnativenativenative (Recruiting)nativenative (Surveys)native (headcount planning, comp bands)native (LMS)native8

The full order under these weights

Weights for this situation, fixed before scoring: build 25, agents 20, fit 15, openness 15, trust 10, ttv 10, pricing 5.
RankPlatformBuild (25)Agents (20)Openness (15)Time to value (10)Pricing (5)Fit (15)Trust (10)Total
1Shapes99888898.6
2Humaans77952776.9
3Rippling87734876.9
4Factorial66845866.4
5Workday57662786.1
6HiBob55853876.0
7Personio64663865.8
8Lattice45777665.6
9BambooHR46758555.4
10Deel35866665.4
11Gusto14679333.9
12Paylocity34322553.6
13ADP32332443.0
14Sage11247242.2

Sources

  1. Shapes pricing, read 8 Nov 2026

Last reviewed 10 Nov 2026.